Showing posts with label QE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label QE. Show all posts

Thursday, May 2, 2013

The QE Cocaine: Commodity bulls begin to snort


Last Updated : 30 April 2013 at 05:25 IST
Quantitative Easing is deemed the holy grail of monetary policy. Unconventional, out-of-the-box, revolutionary and least of all evolutionary, the QE measures are something that everybody looks forward to these days; investors, traders, hedge funds, in short all market participants.
The markets have become QE fetish to such an extent that QE is now deemed the new-normal in monetary policy. It has become an addiction: QE is the market version of cocaine! No QE, no feel good.
Now we also know there is a widespread consensus that politicians are a lazy lot. They always seem to find the populist DNA of things that would significantly contribute to their account balance in electoral banks.
Building and constructing one’s way out of a recession is tough and warrants industrious days and sleepless nights from the people (and hence the least populist), but floating a QE and creating a feel good is easier. You just have to keep the Mints busy, as simple as that!
In a QE measure, the governments often buy back the debts they have issued. These debts are often borne by the financial behemoths in the first place. They often happen to be banks. What they are supposed to do with the money is to enhance lending.
But, in a crisis that has been sparked by reckless lending, these banks would find it prohibitive to lend. Besides, it is easy money that they have got in their kitty as the central bank would have bought back the debt paying a premium so as to incentivise a debt sale by these financial institutions.
In other words, the price you have to pay to own some debt would have significantly gone up in the market place when Bernanke, or for that matter any other central bank chief, begins to discuss this initiative.
What these banks do is, they invest this cheap money in equities and commodities and whatever other lucrative investments they can put their hands on.
When billions in money hit the markets, markets invariably go up; there is a feel-good everywhere. Bulls go for their victory lap and bears retreat. Everybody makes a kill.
Not bad!
But the feel good has a dangerous political side to it. When people mistakenly feel that a single dose of QE is capable to address their issues, the issue on the other hand remains unaddressed. It would lie dormant for a while or simply changes its status to stealth mode.
Hence, once the first round of QE waves subside, it so happens that the market loses momentum. The core reason behind the financial crisis once again tumbles out of the closet. And that is ugly. So there is clamour for the next round of shot. And governments dance to the tune. QE2 follows!
This serial killing or slow poisoning continues until the economy would turn hyper inflationary.
Now that the price of gold has come down significantly along with all other commodities, except for agriculture commodities, there are hopes of QE measures to be maintained by the markets. But the said need is not presented in the way people would understand.
It reads like this: “futures on the Comex climbed on speculation that the US Federal Reserve would continue to maintain aggressive buying of bonds and securities…” we know the language; we have been here before. We know that another shot is necessary, we crave for it, and we are just infants who want to be spoon-fed.
The bulls who snort.
What a pity! 

Saturday, April 27, 2013

US, China Monetary Easing measures may be ruled out; not Eurozone


Last Updated : 24 April 2013 at 15:00 IST
It is greed and fear that drives the markets. But what drives the economy is hope. When it comes to economics of commodities, the ultimate hope is the hope of Quantitative Easing.
We know it all started with the Great Recession.
Unconventional monetary tools were suddenly deployed to create a new normal with a hope to draw some sanity from them. US, Europe, China, Japan, India...the list of regions and nations that employed stimulus measures goes endless.
Now, the sudden spurt in gold, silver and copper prices is attributed to a new round of hope of monetary easing. This hope has arrived because the economic activity around the world is exhibiting signs of slowdown.
Just go through the recent numbers:
Factory activity in the US for April--preliminary, factory purchasing managers' index fell to 52.0 this month from 54.6 in March--expanded at its slowest pace in six months. But the housing sales data at their second-highest level in 3 years provided some anchor.
HSBC Flash China Manufacturing PMI for April gave a reading of 50.5 compared to 51.6 in March. A reading above 50 is indicative of expansion in the economy. But the dip from March levels is surely a cause of concern.
Flash China Manufacturing Output Index provided a reading of 51.1 compared to 53.0 in March, a two-month low.
Private sector activity in Eurozone too declined, amid business activity in Germany dropping.
All these economic events are pointing towards yet another possibility of a fresh round of global easing measures, analysts say. Will that be the case?
The case of US
We know that in US a round of stimulus measures is already underway. The US Federal Reserve is currently running its fourth round of Quantitative Easing measures. The latest round of easing is seeing to it that $85 billion in bonds and Mortgage Backed Securities are purchased by the US Federal Reserve on a monthly basis.
“I don't think there will be an additional round of Quantitative Easing measures from US. On the contrary they are seeking to exit the stimulus measures as exiting is also important.” said V.K. Vijayakumar, Chief Investment Strategist, Geojit BNP Paribas, South India.
The US Federal Reserve has tied QE measures to a positive evolution of job markets and a healthy inflation. Latest data suggests that unemployment rate in different US States dipped in March year on year including California where joblessness dipped to a low in 4 years. The housing bubble in US which invited the global downturn had destroyed the associated job markets there on a substantial scale.
Now, with new home sales and housing starts gaining momentum, US economy is trudging on a path of return. For instance, new housing starts climbed 7% in March from February to touch an annual rate of 1,036,000, and were up by 46.7 percent compared to March 2012.
"The good news is that the recovery is spreading beyond the [San Francisco] Bay Area. There are parts of southern California, such as Los Angeles County, that were badly hit by the housing crash, that are showing signs of recovery," California, he said Reuters, "is emerging again as an economic growth leader led by traditional strengths in technology, trade, tourism, agriculture and the application of creativity to the design of goods and services in demand worldwide".
This trend, if it sustains can see a phase out of Quantitative Easing.
Also, it has to be noted that the jobless claims in US climbed 4000 in figures to a seasonally adjusted 352,000 for the week ending April 13. However, the rise was in line with the expectations fielded by economists even as the claims stood near a line economists normally associate with average monthly job gains of more than 150,000.
The US recovery may at best be termed fragile, and a few indicators are not sufficient enough to hold forth the true picture. Nonetheless, it gives a picture and sunshine as of now outshines the shadows.
So, one can say that another round of monetary stimulus measures is least forthcoming from US.
The case of Europe
An April 4 report appeared in the Bloomberg hints at the possibility of a stimulus measure to be adopted by Eurozone.
“We are considering both standard and non-standard measures” to increase stimulus, ECB President Mario Draghi was quoted by Bloomberg. He was mum on what the tools are.
“Our monetary policy stance will remain accommodative for as long as needed,” Draghi said at a press conference in Frankfurt today after the ECB kept its benchmark interest rate at a record low of 0.75 percent. “We will assess all the incoming data in the coming weeks and we stand ready to act.”
Meanwhile, in Europe, the Eurozone nations cannot think of stimulus measures as Germany has vehement opposition to such a move.
"The deficit reduction in the eurozone must continue," said Wolfgang Schäuble, the German finance minister raising his voice over and above stimulus measures; after all, Schauble is the pay master of the Eurozone. 
"Europe can't function without solving the structural problems." he added.
Germany is still haunted by the specter of hyper inflation episode it experienced in its formative years.
Now, if Germany will have its way, then chances are more that Eurozone would maintain the current status of depressive growth.
However, the picture is not definitive as Gavin Hewitt Europe Editor of The BBC notes in a an analysis titled 'Europe: Retreat from austerity':
Like the arrival of a new season, all the signs are that Europe is in retreat from austerity.
The retreat is disguised, but cannot be concealed. The President of the European Commission, Jose Manuel Barroso, said: "While I think 'austerity' is fundamentally right, I think it has reached its limit."
He implied that a policy can only be pursued if it has "a minimum of political and social support". There is not a general recanting yet, but the explanations are flying thick and fast as to why the policy that Europe has embraced for the past three years must change.
"A period of reduced spending and borrowing was necessary to calm markets concerned about out-of-control debt levels, particularly in peripheral European countries. That time has passed." The EU's Economics Commissioner, Olli Rehn, too said.
If this idea goes viral, chances are more that the Eurozone austerity drive would come to an end even as Germany would be forced to tow the stimulus line. After all, the German economy is also slowing down.
The case of China
Meanwhile, in China, yet another big economy, there are problems of inflation and asset bubbles. “This would deter the Chinese leadership from employing yet another round of stimulus measures,” Vijayakumar noted.
While additional stimulus measures by US and China can be ruled out, the same cannot be the case for Eurozone. The general mood of Eurozone is drifting towards consumption/stimulus led growth rather than austerity driven recovery.

Saturday, April 13, 2013

QE's future in light of FOMC minutes: Slow reversal going forward

Last Updated : 21 February 2013 at 13:10 IST

“To support a stronger economic recovery and to help ensure that inflation, over time, is at the rate most consistent with its dual mandate, the Committee will continue purchasing additional agency mortgage-backed securities at a pace of $40 billion per month and longer-term Treasury securities at a pace of $45 billion per month”, read the minutes of the Federal Open Market Committee that met on January 29-30.
This means that Quantitative Easing measures are safe for now, but reading further, we could see that more of eyebrows have been raised by the committee members. Before that, a backdrop cast:
The US Federal Reserve has been purchasing MBS or Mortgage Backed Securities to the tune of $40 billion per month and longer-term Treasury securities at a pace of $45 billion per month for quite a while, known as multi-stage QE measures. This has been done to improve the growth scenario and thereby boost employment in the economy. (The Fed, as per many analysts, has already spent at least a trillion, if not more to boost the economy since the advent of the Great Recession in 2008.)
The current scheme of QE, though open-ended is tethered to recovery in job market. As of December, the US unemployment rate is hovering at 7.8% way above the widely assumed Fed target of 6.5%. But economic indicators in US charting an upward trajectory have prompted the dissent in the FOMC when it comes to QE measures.
“A number of participants stated that an ongoing evaluation of the efficacy, costs, and risks of asset purchases might well lead the Committee to taper or end its purchases before it judged that a substantial improvement in the outlook for the labor market had occurred. Several others argued that the potential costs of reducing or ending asset purchases too soon were also significant, or that asset purchases should continue until a substantial improvement in the labor market outlook had occurred.” the latest minutes said.
This gives a mixed outlook. Nonetheless we can see a clear orientation towards ending of QE measures gaining strength.
“We can see a dissenting voice in the minutes, but no consensus emerging amongst the members to end QE measures.” said V.K.Vijayakumar, Investment Strategist with Geojit BNP Paribas, India. He believes that QE will not be ended abruptly as it may have adverse effects on economic growth, employment, and price stability. “When it comes to QE, I expect a slow reversal going forward.” he said.
The commodities rally have a liquidity supply in QE measures, but the same may not be in store for perpetuity.
Take for example the case of crude oil.
“With growth in developed markets slowing down there has been no fundamentals supporting the price rally. Yet the deluge of liquidity buoyed the crude oil prices up.” Vijayakumar said.
And yes, taking into account the economic perspective, he has been bearish on gold for some time.

Saturday, January 26, 2013

'Ben Bernanke may not terminate but phase out QE'


Last Updated : 14 January 2013 at 12:15 IST
On Tuesday morning at 2.30 AM IST, Ben Bernanke will rise from his seat to address a gathering at University of Michigan:
“Bernanke, chairman of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, will speak at U-M as part of the Policy Talks @ the Ford School lecture series. The talk, which is free and open to the public, will take place 4-5:30 in Rackham Auditorium.” the event calendar at University of Michigan reads.
The speech addressing the public is deemed the single most important event of the day: the first address since December FOMC—Federal Open Marcket Committee-- minutes that was interpreted by the investor community as a premonition to the termination of QE measures; if not buy all, at least by some.
So, will Bernanke wave a red flag on the face of investor community signalling a termination to QE measures?
“I don't think so...as it would be a premature measure.” said Kunal Shah, Head of Commodity Research of Nirmal Bang Commodities, Bangalore.
“The unemployment is still ruling high in the US economy and the jobless claims have gone up. Inflation is at around 2%-2.5%. The factors that prompted Fed to announce QE measures are still in place.” he pointed out.
US unemployment rates have fallen below 7% even as U.S. unemployment benefits rose 4,000 to a seasonally adjusted 371,000; 7% is way too below a comfortable level.
“However, if he hints at a QE, say by December, which is highly unlikley, the markets would be concerned. But I don't think it will happen.” Kunal Shah explained.
Gradual phasing out? 
But QE measures cannot go on for ever...
“There could be a gradual phasing out of QE measures, and I expect the same to begin towards the end of this year.” said Vijayakumar, Investment Strategist at Geojit BNP Paribas.
The US bond yields climbing is a signal in this regard and the markets have already discounted the possibility. US Bond yields—a measure of risk propensity of bonds—have climbed towards 1.87%, which shows a “gradual migration from debt markets to equity markets.” Vijayakumar added.
“Nobody would end QE abruptly as it would rattle the markets.” he concluded.
So, the helicopter Ben—as Bernanke is often described—will not signal a QE termination this time around, but could hint at a gradual phasing out of measures.